The Enduring Shadow: Unpacking "Kugarira Vana" and the Silent Suffering of Women in Zimbabwean Marriages

In the Zimbabwean society, where family is the bedrock of community, a silent struggle often unfolds within the confines of marriage,
particularly for women who find themselves trapped in difficult circumstances.
This phenomenon, colloquially known as "kugarira vana" (literally meaning "staying for the children"), describes the painful decision by a woman to remain in a marriage,
despite experiencing mistreatment, infidelity, and neglect from her husband, all in the perceived best interest of her children.
While rooted in a profound maternal instinct and societal pressure, "kugarira vana" raises critical questions about women's well-being, their human rights, and the long-term outcomes for both the women and the children they seek to protect.

This article delves into the multi-faceted dynamics of "kugarira vana" in modern Zimbabwe, exploring the complex reasons women endure such hardships,
the various forms of suffering they face, the true costs versus perceived benefits, and critically examining whether such a sacrifice is truly "worth it" in the long run.

The Enduring Shadow

Understanding "Kugarira Vana": Roots in Zimbabwean Society

"Kugarira vana" is not merely a personal choice but a reflection of deeply entrenched cultural norms, economic realities, and societal expectations that shape women's lives in Zimbabwe.

Cultural Imperatives: Traditional Shona (and other Zimbabwean) cultures place immense value on family unity and the sanctity of marriage.
Divorce is often stigmatised, viewed as a failure that brings shame upon the woman and her family (mhuri).
A woman leaving her marriage, especially if she is seen as the initiator, might face social ostracism, particularly in rural communities where communal ties are paramount.
The ideal is to raise children within a two-parent household, however dysfunctional.
Maternal Instinct and Protection: At its core, "kugarira vana" stems from a woman's profound love and desire to protect her children.
She believes that staying provides stability, prevents them from being labelled as children of divorce, ensures their access to paternal resources (even if limited), and shields them from the perceived difficulties of growing up in a broken home or with a single mother.
The Role of Lobola (Bride Price): The practice of roora (or lobola) payment, while a symbol of honour and commitment, can sometimes complicate a woman's exit from an abusive marriage.
The husband's family might demand repayment of roora if the woman initiates divorce, a sum her own family may be unable or unwilling to pay, effectively holding her hostage in the marriage.
Fear of the Unknown: Leaving a marriage, especially without an independent income or a strong support system, can lead to destitution for both the woman and her children.
The fear of poverty, homelessness, and social judgment often outweighs the desire for personal freedom and happiness.

The Unseen Battle: Forms of Suffering Endured

Women practising "kugarira vana" often endure a spectrum of mistreatment, much of which remains hidden behind closed doors.
The suffering is multifaceted, eroding their well-being on every level.

1. Emotional and Psychological Abuse:

This is perhaps the most insidious and pervasive form of suffering.
Constant criticism, belittling, threats, gas-lighting, control over finances, isolation from family and friends, and the profound pain of infidelity can lead to:

Erosion of Self-Worth: A woman's self-esteem can be utterly shattered, leading to feelings of worthlessness, guilt, and inadequacy.
Chronic Stress and Anxiety: Living in a state of hyper-vigilance, anticipating the next insult or act of cruelty, results in persistent anxiety, fear, and emotional exhaustion.
Depression: The relentless emotional toll often culminates in depression, characterised by hopelessness, lack of motivation, and profound sadness.
Loss of Identity and Agency: Over time, a woman may lose her sense of self, becoming solely defined by her suffering and her role as a sacrificing mother.
Her ability to make independent decisions or envision a different future diminishes.

2. Neglect and Abandonment (Emotional & Financial):

Even if physically present, a husband who mistreats his wife or is constantly absent due to infidelity or other pursuits essentially abandons her emotionally.
This often extends to financial neglect, where the husband fails to provide adequately for the family, leaving the woman to shoulder the burden, often without her own income.

Increased Burden: The woman becomes the sole provider and caregiver, struggling to meet daily needs while dealing with emotional pain.
Resentment and Bitterness: Over time, unacknowledged sacrifices and unreciprocated effort can breed deep resentment towards the husband and, sometimes, even towards the children for whom the sacrifice is being made.

3. Infidelity and Betrayal:

Cheating, a common catalyst for women choosing "kugarira vana," is a profound act of betrayal.
Beyond the immediate pain, it can expose the woman to sexually transmitted infections, including HIV, adding a layer of physical and life-threatening risk to her emotional suffering.
The constant awareness of her husband's infidelity can be a source of continuous humiliation and anguish.

4. Physical Abuse (often escalating):

While not always present at the outset of "kugarira vana," a marriage marked by emotional abuse and neglect can often escalate to physical violence.
Women who stay, hoping for change or for the children's sake, may find themselves increasingly vulnerable to physical harm, turning their home into a dangerous environment.

The "Worth It" Dilemma: Perceived Benefits vs. Actual Costs

The central question for women in "kugarira vana" is whether the perceived benefits for their children truly outweigh the immense personal cost.

Perceived Benefits (from the woman's and societal perspective):

Children Grow Up with Both Parents: The belief that a two-parent home, regardless of its quality, is always better.
Financial Stability for Children: The hope that the father will continue to provide, even minimally.
Avoiding Social Stigma: Protecting children from the stigma of being from a divorced home, and the mother from the stigma of being a single parent.
Preserving Family Name/Assets: Maintaining the family unit and lineage, especially regarding inherited land or property.
Hope for Change: The enduring belief that the husband might eventually change, or that the situation will improve.

Actual Costs and Outcomes:

For the Woman:

Profound Psychological Trauma: Long-term exposure to abuse and neglect can lead to Complex Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (C-PTSD), severe depression, anxiety disorders, and chronic low self-esteem.
Physical Health Deterioration: Chronic stress has tangible physical consequences, contributing to hypertension, heart disease, autoimmune disorders, and weakened immunity. The added risk of STIs from infidelity is also a major concern.
Lost Potential and Stagnation: The woman's personal growth, career aspirations, and overall life satisfaction are severely curtailed. She may become emotionally stagnant, unable to pursue her own happiness or well-being.
Social Isolation: Abusive partners often isolate their wives, and the shame associated with their situation can lead women to withdraw from friends and family, deepening their loneliness.
Intergenerational Cycle of Abuse: By modeling an unhealthy relationship, the mother may inadvertently teach her children that abuse and unhappiness are normal or expected in marriage.

For the Children:

Witnessing Abuse is Trauma: Children who live in homes where a parent is verbally, emotionally, or physically abused are deeply traumatized themselves. They may develop:
- Emotional and Behavioural Problems: Anxiety, depression, aggression, poor academic performance, and difficulty forming healthy relationships.
- Distorted Views of Relationships: They learn that love involves suffering, that men can mistreat women with impunity, or that women must sacrifice their happiness. Boys might replicate the abusive patterns of their fathers, while girls might become drawn to similar partners.
- Attachment Issues: The lack of emotional safety and stability can lead to insecure attachment styles, affecting their future bonds.
- Feelings of Guilt and Responsibility: Children often internalise the marital problems, blaming themselves or feeling responsible for their mother's unhappiness.
Lack of Genuine Stability: While the structure of a two-parent home may exist, the emotional instability and conflict within it often negate any perceived benefits. A chaotic home, even with both parents, is far less nurturing than a stable single-parent home.
Financial Insecurity (Often): The father's mistreatment often extends to financial neglect, meaning children may still face poverty and lack of resources, despite their mother's sacrifice.

Societal Angles and Legal Gaps

The perpetuation of "kugarira vana" is also sustained by broader societal structures and sometimes inadequate legal frameworks in Zimbabwe.

Patriarchy and Gender Inequality: Deep-seated patriarchal attitudes in some Zimbabwean communities grant men significant power and privilege, often at the expense of women's rights. These attitudes normalise male dominance and may excuse abusive behaviours.
Economic Disempowerment of Women: Many women in Zimbabwe lack economic independence, making it difficult to leave a marriage even if it is harmful. Limited access to education, formal employment, and control over financial resources leaves them vulnerable.
Ineffective Legal Redress: While Zimbabwean law protects women from abuse and allows for divorce, implementation can be challenging. Customary law, which often governs marital disputes in traditional settings, can sometimes disadvantage women, particularly concerning property rights and child custody, reinforcing the idea that leaving is too difficult.
Lack of Support Services: Accessible and affordable legal aid, safe shelters, psychological counselings, and economic empowerment programs for women are often limited, especially outside major urban centers.

Conclusion: A Call for Dignity and Well-being

The practice of "kugarira vana," while born from a mother's profound love and societal pressures, inflicts deep and lasting wounds.
The perceived benefits of maintaining a fractured family structure rarely outweigh the devastating costs to the woman's physical and mental health, her dignity, and often, to the very children she seeks to protect.
Children growing up in environments of chronic marital conflict and abuse are not truly "protected"; they are witnesses to a form of trauma that shapes their understanding of love, relationships, and self-worth.

For society to truly empower women and protect children in Zimbabwe, it is imperative to:

Challenge Harmful Norms: Actively dismantle the stigma around divorce and single motherhood, recognising that a woman's well-being is paramount.
Empower Women Economically: Invest in women's education, skills training, and access to financial resources, giving them the agency to make independent choices.
Strengthen Legal Protections: Ensure that legal frameworks are accessible, effective, and prioritise the safety and rights of women and children over outdated customs that trap them.
Increase Support Services: Expand access to counselings, safe housing, and legal aid for women experiencing domestic abuse.
Engage Men in Dialogue: Foster conversations among men about healthy masculinity, respectful relationships, and the true meaning of partnership and fatherhood.

Ultimately, "kugarira vana" is a testament to the immense resilience of Zimbabwean women, but it is a resilience born of pain and sacrifice.
True progress lies in creating a society where no woman has to choose between her own well-being and the perceived best interest of her children, where dignity, respect, and emotional safety are non-negotiable foundations for every marriage.
It is a future where every Zimbabwean child grows up in a home defined not by endurance, but by genuine love, peace, and mutual respect.

Adverts Here

Welcome To Cathrine James's Blog: Cathrine James is one of Zimbabwe’s top female marketers, with an impressive career and invaluable experience from the Marketers Association of Zimbabwe (MAZ).

Contact Us through the Chat with WhatsApp widget below.